Lobsters Were Really Cheap

Lobster may not be considered an unconventional food in the present day, but that is not the reason for its inclusion in this list. In colonial America, lobsters were abundantly available and consuming them regularly was perceived as a marker of being part of the lower social class. As mentioned above, they even used them as bait for eels!
My, my, how the times have changed. In present times, lobster has become one of the priciest seafood options, while eels, on the other hand, are unlikely to be used as bait when considering a lobster purchase. The tables have certainly turned!