More About the Lizzie Borden House, Fall River, Massachusetts

At first, no one even suspected Lizzie as a culprit. But there was too much circumstantial evidence against her. Her statement simply did not make sense that she was out in the barn at the time of the murders: since it was discovered that Mrs. Borden was murdered a few hours before her husband, the killer would have had to lie in wait for his next victim inside the house, which was not possible with the servants and Lizzie running around. She was also seen burning a dress she claimed was too soiled to wear any longer.
Another point of interest here is that, at the time of questioning, Lizzie claimed that her mother had gone out to see a friend after having received a note. The note, however, was never discovered. Lizzie tried to dispute this by saying that her stepmother could have burned the letter before going out.

Lizzie’s trial lasted two weeks. She was eventually found not guilty, even after testimony from a pharmacist claiming that just the day before the murders, Lizzie had come into his store asking to purchase cyanide, which she needed a prescription for before she could buy. After the trial, Lizzie and her sister left the house and bought a new one in Fall River.