American as Apple Pie

Not everything on this list is intended to be peculiar or off-putting. Colonial Americans adored apple pie, despite the fact that apples originated in Europe and were not native to North America. Apples grew well in the colonies because the fruit can survive the harsh winters, and Americans took the apples and made pies much like we still enjoy today.
Apple pie during that era was likely less sweet compared to its modern counterpart, primarily due to the scarcity and high cost of sugar, which was considered a luxury item. However, it was still seasoned with nutmeg or cinnamon, and we’re sure it was just as delicious as we know it is today!