The Edison Myth Unraveled: 27 Inventions He Claimed But Didn’t Create

Home Editor Picks The Edison Myth Unraveled: 27 Inventions He Claimed But Didn’t Create

The Edison Myth Unraveled: 27 Inventions He Claimed But Didn’t Create

By Chu E. - March 31, 2025

Thomas Edison’s name echoes through history as America’s greatest inventor. School textbooks praise his genius while museums display his creations. Yet a darker truth lurks behind the myth. Many celebrated inventions attributed to Edison came from other brilliant minds who lacked his wealth, connections, and marketing savvy. Let’s examine 25 inventions commonly credited to Edison that he didn’t truly create.

NEXT >>

The Incandescent Light Bulb: Edison’s Most Famous “Theft”

The Edison Myth Unraveled: 27 Inventions He Claimed But Didn’t Create — Source: smartgrids-electricity-vehicles.com

Joseph Swan developed a working incandescent bulb in England a full year before Edison’s 1879 patent. Hiram Maxim had also created a similar design. Swan successfully sued Edison for patent infringement in British courts. Edison simply found the right filament material for commercial production. His money and business acumen overshadowed the inventors who did the groundbreaking work first.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

The Phonograph: Building on Scott’s Phonautograph

Edison’s 1877 phonograph brought him international fame. The crucial precursor came from Édouard-Léon Scott, who invented the phonautograph in 1857 to record sound waves visually. Charles Cros independently conceived a sound reproduction method similar to Edison’s months before Edison’s demonstration. Edison added playback capability, but the fundamental concept wasn’t his original idea.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Electric Power Distribution System: Faraday’s and Gramme’s Legacy

Edison launched Pearl Street Station in 1882, powering New York City. Michael Faraday established the electromagnetic principles decades earlier. Zénobe Gramme developed the practical DC dynamo Edison merely adapted. The core components existed before Edison touched them. His team optimized the network while his money let him deploy what others invented but couldn’t afford to implement.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Quadruplex Telegraph: Built Upon Stearns’ Foundation

Edison’s 1874 quadruplex telegraph sent four messages over one wire simultaneously. Joseph Stearns had already created a duplex telegraph (two messages) six years earlier. Samuel Morse established the basics. Edison merely improved existing technology. African-American inventor Granville T. Woods created similar systems but faced racial barriers Edison never encountered.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Storage Battery: Stolen From Swedish Innovation

Edison patented the nickel-iron battery in 1901. Swedish scientist Waldemar Jungner had developed nearly identical technology two years earlier. Henri Tudor had already explored alkaline batteries before either of them. Jungner worked with limited funding while Edison commanded vast resources. Jungner couldn’t match Edison’s manufacturing scale or army of patent lawyers.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Mimeograph: Zuccato Got There First

Edison’s “Autographic Printing” device from 1876 revolutionized copying. Eugenio de Zuccato had patented his “papyrograph” two years earlier. James Watt used similar concepts in the 18th century. Albert Blake Dick later licensed Edison’s patent and coined the term “mimeograph.” Edison created a practical stencil method but took credit for a concept that existed before his version.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Talking Doll: Built On Centuries of Automata

Edison’s 1890 phonograph doll recited nursery rhymes. Johann Nepomuk Maelzel had created mechanical talking devices decades earlier. Edison simply combined his phonograph with existing toy concepts. His employees performed much of the actual development. The project flopped commercially due to poor sound quality, yet Edison’s name alone appeared on the patent.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Concrete Furniture: Ancient Rome Did It First

Edison’s system for casting concrete houses seemed innovative in the 1910s. Romans mastered concrete construction thousands of years earlier. François Coignet pioneered modern reinforced concrete buildings in the 1860s. Employee Henry Callahan helped refine Edison’s process. Edison merely applied mass production techniques to ancient building methods, generating fame despite limited practical success.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Stock Ticker: Calahan’s Invention Refined

Edison patented his improved stock ticker in 1869. Edward Calahan had invented the original just two years earlier. David Hughes developed telegraph printing devices before either of them. Edison simply made Calahan’s design more reliable and faster. He sold it to Western Union for $40,000. His business savvy eclipsed Calahan, whose name faded while Edison’s grew.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Electric Pen: Adaptation of Existing Technology

Edison’s 1876 electric pen created stencils for document duplication. John Rand and Samuel O’Reilly had already worked on similar perforating tools. O’Reilly’s device later evolved into the modern tattoo machine. Edison added electricity to improve what already existed. Lesser-known inventors couldn’t match Edison’s marketing machine, so their foundational work went unrecognized.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Tasimeter: Academic Science Commercialized

Edison’s tasimeter from 1878 measured infrared radiation and tiny temperature changes. Samuel Langley and John Draper had already created similar sensitive heat-measuring instruments for astronomy. Edison built a portable version using his carbon button technology. Scientists focused on research rather than commercialization, so Edison’s publicity during a solar eclipse gave him undue credit.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Magnetic Ore Separator: European Mining Technology

Edison patented his magnetic ore separator in the 1880s. Peter von Rittinger and European engineers had used magnetic separation since the 1850s. The principles relied on Faraday’s work on electromagnetism. Edison employee William Dickson helped improve the machinery. Edison simply scaled up existing technology for industrial use, though his mining venture ultimately failed financially.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Dynamo Improvements: Gramme Did the Hard Part

Edison’s power system relied on improved dynamos. Zénobe Gramme had built the first efficient DC dynamo in 1871. Werner von Siemens and Antonio Pacinotti advanced the technology throughout the 1860s. Charles Batchelor helped Edison optimize efficiency. Their team improved output for commercial distribution. European inventors focused less on American patents, allowing Edison to dominate the U.S. narrative.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Automatic Telegraph: Wheatstone’s Idea Accelerated

Edison’s 1871 automatic telegraph sped message transmission with perforated tape. George Little and Charles Wheatstone had developed similar high-speed telegraphy methods in the 1850s. Edison added chemical recording methods to their foundation. His refinements made the system practical for Western Union. The core concepts came from inventors who lacked Edison’s commercial connections.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Vote Recorder: Electrifying Existing Concepts

Edison’s first 1869 patent covered an electric vote tallying device. Henry Highton had proposed mechanical vote counters years earlier. Edison simply added electricity to a proven concept. Lawmakers rejected the device anyway, preferring slower manual counts that allowed political maneuvering. Earlier mechanical versions went unpatented, giving Edison official credit despite limited originality.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Spirit Phone: Spiritualists’ Techniques Rebranded

Edison claimed to work on a “spirit phone” to contact the dead in the 1920s. Spiritualists like John Murray Spear had experimented with similar devices for decades. Edison combined his phonograph and electrical knowledge, though no working device materialized. Earlier fringe inventors faced ridicule. Edison’s scientific reputation gave supernatural claims credibility they didn’t deserve.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Electrographic Vote Recorder: Bain’s Fax Machine Reimagined

Edison’s 1875 electrographic vote recorder resembled an early fax machine. Alexander Bain had invented a facsimile device for transmitting images via telegraph in 1843, over thirty years earlier. Giovanni Caselli commercialized a “pantelegraph” in the 1860s. Edison refined image transmission for practical application while European pioneers faded beneath Edison’s growing legend.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Odoroscope: Speculative Science Claimed

Edison’s 1891 “odoroscope” claimed to detect odors electronically. Heinrich Hertz had already explored electrical sensitivity to chemicals. Perfumers like Septimus Piesse studied odor classification long before Edison. The device remained mostly theoretical, never fully realized. Earlier researchers published findings but didn’t rush to patent offices. Edison’s name is attached to the concept despite minimal impact.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Kinetoscope: Dickson Did the Work

Edison patented the Kinetoscope motion picture viewer in 1891. William Kennedy Dickson, an Edison employee, actually developed it while Edison focused elsewhere. Dickson built on Muybridge’s zoopraxiscope and Marey’s chronophotographic gun. Edison provided facilities and funding but minimal direct input. Dickson eventually left Edison’s lab, frustrated by lack of recognition.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Fluoroscope: Röntgen’s X-Ray Application

Edison claimed to improve medical imaging with his fluoroscope after Wilhelm Röntgen discovered X-rays in 1895. Röntgen had already built the first fluoroscope. Edison experimented with materials to enhance screen brightness. His assistant Clarence Dally conducted most experiments, suffering radiation damage that killed him. Edison abandoned X-ray research after Dally’s death but kept his name on the patents.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Carbon Transmitter: Edison’s Telephone “Improvement”

Edison improved Bell’s telephone with a carbon transmitter in 1877. German inventor Philipp Reis had created a similar device in 1861, sixteen years earlier. Emile Berliner filed a caveat for a carbon transmitter hours before Edison. All these inventors built on existing carbon-based resistance technologies. Edison’s legal team pushed his claim forward, leading to lengthy patent battles.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Wax Paper Carbon Copy: Building on European Innovation

Edison claimed the carbon copy process with his 1876 patent. Italian inventor Pellegrino Turri created carbon paper around 1806 for his mechanical typing machine. Ralph Wedgwood patented “carbonated paper” in England the same year. Edison adapted existing methods for his electric pen system. The concept had been commercially available for decades. Edison packaged the technology more effectively, but did not invent it.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Vitascope: Armat’s Projector Rebranded

America’s first commercial film projector in 1896 bore Edison’s name. Thomas Armat and Charles Francis Jenkins actually invented and patented the device. Edison purchased the rights and marketed it as “Edison’s Vitascope.” The original inventors faded into obscurity while Edison claimed another technological milestone. Edison’s contribution consisted mainly of attaching his famous name to someone else’s machine.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Electric Railway: Siemens Beat Edison by Years

Edison demonstrated an electric railway at Menlo Park in 1880. Werner von Siemens had already built and operated one in Berlin two years earlier. Stephen Field had filed American patents for electric railways before Edison. The technology existed in multiple countries already. Edison simply demonstrated an American version on his property. The press, enamored with Edison, gave him disproportionate credit.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Dictaphone: Building on Bell and Tainter’s Graphophone

Edison claimed to invent the first dictation machine in the 1880s. Alexander Graham Bell, Charles Tainter, and Chichester Bell had already developed the graphophone for office dictation in 1886. Edison modified his phonograph for business use after seeing their success. Columbia Phonograph Company battled Edison for years. Edison’s marketing created the impression he pioneered office recording despite arriving second.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Perforated Underlayer Paper: Existing Technology Adopted

Edison patented perforated underlayer paper for his electric pen in 1876. European stationers had used similar methods for copying since the early 19th century. Edison adapted existing manufacturing approaches to fit his electric pen system. The fundamental technology existed for decades. His contribution focused on commercialization rather than invention. Edison’s patent obscured the long history of perforated paper techniques.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Bamboo Filament: Edison’s Team Did the Work

Edison received credit for discovering that bamboo made excellent light bulb filaments in 1880. Employee Charles Batchelor conducted most experiments, testing thousands of materials. William Moore specifically identified the bamboo species that worked best. Japanese scientists had explored plant fibers for similar uses. Edison directed research but didn’t personally make the discovery. His name alone appeared on patents despite the team effort.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

The Team Behind Edison’s Success

Edison employed over 200 scientists, engineers, and craftsmen at his peak. Lewis Latimer, an African-American inventor, improved the carbon filament for light bulbs but rarely gets credit. Nikola Tesla worked for Edison before their famous rivalry. Edison paid these brilliant minds modest salaries while claiming their innovations as his own. His factories manufactured what others conceptualized, a pattern defining his career.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Edison’s Real Genius: The Patent System

Edison filed 1,093 patents during his lifetime, showcasing his true superpower: exploiting America’s patent system. His legal team dedicated itself to filing patents and challenging competitors. Edison understood that legal ownership trumped original invention. He purchased patents from struggling inventors when advantageous. His famous quote about genius being mostly perspiration takes new meaning when considering his lawyers’ efforts.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

The Man Behind the Myths

Edison wasn’t an inventor so much as a businessman with an eye for potential. His genius lay in recognizing good ideas, improving them marginally, then patenting and marketing them aggressively. His Menlo Park laboratory employed brilliant engineers who often did the real work. His money purchased not just equipment but the right to claim credit. History should acknowledge the forgotten minds behind “Edison’s” greatest hits.

<< Previous