2. Identity Crisis (2004)
Brad Meltzer’s Identity Crisis pulled no punches, confronting readers with shocking themes of rape, murder, and moral conflict within the superhero community. The graphic assault and tragic death of Sue Dibny divided fans, with many questioning the necessity of such mature content in mainstream comics.
The series ignited passionate debates about the ethical implications of using trauma for dramatic effect, and whether it enriched or harmed the genre’s storytelling. This is especially true, given that it is essentially a Justice League comic book series, during a new surge in comic book interest.